Key Policies to Boost Manufacturing: Create a Competitive “Race to the Top”

February 8, 2013 No Comments
Print Friendly

In the second part of a series on boosting American manufacturing, the Brookings Institution makes the case for a nationwide initiative to improve and expand the skilled industrial workforce.

In the wake of the recession, the U.S. economy has shifted its focus onto the critical drivers of economic growth: innovation and production. To stimulate growth, the U.S. must increase exports, reduce waste, and produce more of the key goods that boost business activity. The most effective way to do so is to provide greater support to the manufacturing sector, which leads the way in high-tech innovation and the creation of well-paying jobs.

In the second of a series of key policy recommendations to aid the U.S. economy, the non-partisan Brookings Institution calls for the creation of a national “Race to the Shop” competition, which would challenge U.S. states and metropolitan areas to align their policymaking and investments to meet the labor needs of their primary manufacturing industries.

According to Brookings, America’s advanced manufacturing sector is the linchpin of a strong workforce, providing jobs that pay nearly 20 percent higher average weekly earnings than non-manufacturing jobs. Although manufacturing accounts for only 9 percent of U.S. employment and 11 percent of total GDP, it employs 35 percent of all engineers, accounts for 68 percent of R&D spending, and generates 90 percent of all patents. Moreover, manufactured goods represent 65 percent of U.S. trade.

However, many manufacturers are struggling to find qualified workers who meet the demands of increasingly complex production methods. To help bridge this skills gap, Brookings has proposed an annual $150 million competition – modeled on the Obama administration’s Race to the Top education program – that would modernize federal investment in workforce development and training for advanced manufacturing.

The program is designed to encourage state and metropolitan areas to compete for federal funding by developing long-term plans, investment strategies, and regulatory and administrative reforms that support and strengthen the top manufacturing industries in their region, with a particular focus on skills training and professional development.

“The competition would require a cross-section of leaders from the public, university, non-profit, and private manufacturing sector in states and metro areas to organize a task force (perhaps led at the state level by the governor’s office and at the metro level by a consortium of elected officials or a leading non-profit or manufacturing intermediary) that would be charged with designing and submitting a proposal to address the manufacturing workforce and skills challenges within their state or region,” the report explains.

More specifically, each area competing for investment would present a plan that:

  • Articulates a clear economic vision based on the strengths and specializations of the advanced manufacturing in the region;
  • Identifies key weaknesses and barriers, such as lack of vocational or skills training, to successfully implementing the plan;
  • Presents strategies that bring the plan to fruition through tangible projects and investments involving manufacturing companies;
  • Leverages other federal funds in support of these strategies;
  • Reforms local policies and regulations to bolster the plan; and
  • Provides accountability for governmental and private sector participants through transparent performance measures.

An interagency panel would review submissions and award grants each year to the five states and five metropolitan areas with the strongest plans. The average grant amount would be $15 million, although the totals would vary depending on the size of the area’s industrial base.

The Brookings proposal also aims to boost education in manufacturing skills as another measure to improve the nation’s industrial workforce.

“The Race to the Shop initiative would align with the existing effort to promote the use of manufacturing industry-recognized national skills certifications in the education system,” the report explains. “The goal under Race to the Shop would be to expand this program — particularly with regard to credentials for advanced manufacturing industries — into the secondary and postsecondary curricula in a greater number of states, in order to create a national vocational education system that is better aligned with the employment requirements and standards of the advanced manufacturing industry.

In the first part of the series on strengthening U.S. manufacturing, the Brookings Institution advocated for the establishment of a network of high-tech manufacturing hubs across the country.

Originally published on by Ilya Leybovich | February 7th, 2013. Link to the original published story.


Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.

E-clusive: Enhancing the Image of Manufacturing

By Nancy Huddleston Let’s face it – we’re humans and it’s in our nature to care about our looks...

E-clusive: It’s Time to Evangelize Manufacturing

By Nancy Huddleston It’s not every day that you hear someone say, “we need to evangelize manufacturing as a...